Happy Hispanic Heritage Month?
I had every intention to raise bilingual kids. I had every intention to actually improve – at least maintain – by own level of bilingualism. But, I have to be honest: I suck at raising bilingual kids.
How’s that for a happy Hispanic Heritage Month?
In real life, I often completely forget that I can communicate in Spanish. I allow the fear of making mistakes – the knowledge that I cannot perfectly express my sentiments in Spanish – keep me from practicing the language. This fear often keeps me from feeling whole or isolating the Latino environment that would improve our day to day life. If I feel like my language ability is being judged, I literally refuse to speak it.
How’s that for building a legacy?
Last Friday, as I sat on the grass watching my girl during soccer practice, a dark skinned woman started to approach me. She was gorgeous – long, gentle wavy hair, full make-up on, wearing very stylish attire for the average soccer mom. My heart smiled a little, embracing the stereotype that Latinas are fashion forward and gorgeous; this woman certainly embodied it all. I’m neither, but am proud to be Latina nonetheless.
She sat next to me and, for whatever reason, we started to chat… in Spanish. We sat there a long time, talking about our daughters, soccer, her Etsy business selling stylish hair bows (of which I bought a few). We talked about her hometown in Mexico, how my accent sounded nothing like a Cuban’s should. And we did this all in Spanish.
We sat there and chatted in Spanish as I could feel the glares from other moms who don’t…. I was reminded of the difficulties of being a bicultural Latina in modern day America. I’m reminded of the jokes and ignorant judgments from monolinguals that can’t fathom why anyone (or any American) would want to speak another language. I’m reminded of the hurt I felt when friends or “family” would chastise those who “refuse to speak English” and should “go back to their own country”, as if it were that easy. I’m reminded of how I bit my tongue, wanting to explain that my family members were political refugees, that they were “legal”, that for however fragmented, they could speak English, or that they were successful entrepreneurs making millions of dollars while their monolingual families could hardly pay the bills. I wanted to say all of that, but I always bit my English speaking tongue and hid my harsh, hyphenated realty from my Spanish speaking family. What else can a bicultural Latina do?
Being a bicultural Latina can be as hard as raising bilingual kids… and sometimes I just feel so inadequate in all of it. So much of my parenting revolves around the idea that biracial children can grow up to feel whole (and wholesome) by honoring all elements of their heritage. We are so proud to be American; to be educated English speaking, tax-paying Americans. Pero hijole, does that mean I can’t be bilingual? Because if that’s what it means, then I’m not so sure we can get along.
Until now, I’ve failed to accept how important language is to my parenting philosophy and, because our current lifestyle doesn’t honor those beliefs, the inner dissonance I’m experiencing lately has become way too much to overlook. Things have to change. My kids are getting too old to ignore our bilingual endeavors.
Sure, as of today, I suck at raising bilingual kids. I suck at being proud of my own bilingualism, too. But I’m getting better and we’re making changes. One day at a time, we’re moving towards a life of bilingualism and multiculturalism that I find most important in raising multiracial children. Let’s see where that takes us.
In the meantime, to my fellow bicultural Latinos straddling the hyphen, I wish you a very happy Hispanic Heritage Month.
10 Comments
Missy
September 22, 2014 at 5:44 pmWhat cubano says hijole?
Vanessa
September 23, 2014 at 8:43 amOne raised in Southern California. Are you saying I’m not Cuban, or just trying to be rude?
Danielle
September 24, 2014 at 12:30 amLove, love, love this! For so many reasons! I’ve been studying spanish for a loooooong but that fear of sounding ignorant or failing to know exactly what to say has been such an impediment to me! No more, though! There’s no growth in that! I also want to encourage you to not allow that fear to play a role in practing with your kids. Honestly, the spanish language is represented by so many countries, colors, and cultures that I find so many variations en la lingua! So many of my native speaking friends had to learn the basics of grammar and language arts and that’s okay! Mira, how many native English speakers that have failed English?! And it’s so unfortunate that you encountered such negativity sorrounding being bilingual! It’s honestly, absolutely absurd to me! Its like chasting someone for taking a multivitamin. Outside of being bilingual offering a tremendous edge socially and professionally, it’s been found that it is academically and intellectually beneficial for children to study languages. Chile cheese! I studied French as a child (K-5th grade) but I’ve been studying espanol since high school (college now) but as soon as I round the bend on my profincency in Spanish I will be tightening my Franch. To be frank; anyone who does see the value and beauty in understanding multilingual is dumb as hell and that’s exactly what I would tell them!
Weather Anchor Mama
September 27, 2014 at 12:33 amYou must teach them! I wish my spanish was better, sadly I find myself forgetting words and phrases. I wish I had a better command of the language. Teaching them spanish would give them the upper hand when it comes to jobs and such. I think it’s great that you acknowledge the need to better. Keep me posted on your progress and please share tips for teaching your kids a second language.
Stephanie
October 9, 2014 at 6:36 amMy grandmother was born in Cuba but never spoke a word of Spanish to any of us. I grew up in South Florida and learned Spanish in school and by speaking to members of the community. I still struggle and sometimes worry about the judgement that will come, but I practice with my coworkers who know my commitment to learning the language and speaking it well. The best advice I was given about raising bilingual children in a household where I am the only one who speaks Spanish (which is an overstatement of my ability) was “Just speak it to them. Don’t worry if you are not being grammatically correct or not using advanced vocabulary, especially if they are young. They will learn to hear the language and will perfect it outside of the home. Encourage them to respond in Spanish too so they will develop the confidence to speak it early. “
Vanessa
October 11, 2014 at 6:39 pmI appreciate your comment, Stephanie! We are making BIG life changes going into 2015 and, cross my heart, these kids WILL be bilingual! Mucho amor amiga, Vanessa
Yare
December 28, 2014 at 4:21 pmHi Vanessa. I found you when looking for information about how to take care of my 16 months old daughter’s curly hair. Yo también soy cubana, nacida en Cuba. I have been in the US for 6 years now. SO, anyways, I love your blog and your topics, and why not mention it, the fact that you are Cuban too lol. Talking about raising bilingual kids, which a really good topic. Do you speak Spanish? Like, are you fully bilingual? Because if you are, and your husband’s first language is English, then you have such an advantage there. You could talk to your kids in Spanish all the time, while your husband can do it in Engish. I know of families who do this and it has been a great success. In my case, with our daughter, we have a hard time talking to her in both languages without making it spanglish. My husband is Cuban too, so like me, English is his second language. So, since all we talk is spanish, except at work(my husband) and when we go shopping, etc, that is the language our toddler speaks. Even when I talk to her in English, she would repeat the words in Spanish or answer me in Spanish. In my case I get concerned that she won’t pick English, but I know from other kids who have come from Cuba even at around 10 years old, that they will end up making English their language because of school, friends, TV, etc. So my suggestion, try to talk to them in Spanish while dad talks to them in English, and you might get great results.
Maria
January 27, 2015 at 9:23 amHello, I am a new subscriber to your website. I was looking for way to care for my daughters hair and I found your hair care tips, then I came across this topic of being bilingual. My 7 year old daughter is pretty fluent in both English and Spanish. Growing up I only spoke Spanish to her to make sure she learned it all. As she got older she picked up on English from her older brother. I enrolled her in school at age 4, to attend Pre-K and she was accepted because of her language barrier. She is now in the second grade and takes a dual-language class at her school. She will continue this dual-language class through out her school career. She reads and writes Spanish and English better than her 16 and 12 year old brothers. I believe in the importance of continuing with your heritage and cultures. My 16 year old is in high school and because he already knows the Spanish language I had him take French for his required Foreign language. My 12 year old fell off the band wagon since he was my only child that attended daycare and speaking to him in English just made it easier at the time; which I regret doing. He is now learning Spanish, slowly but surely. Good luck to you with teaching your kids the language. I just wanted to share my story.
Vanessa Bell
January 29, 2015 at 9:49 pmThank you so much, Maria! How wonderful that your children all have various fluency levels. My fluency isn’t all that perfect. so I never felt comfortable speaking solely in Spanish to them… which is silly! We recently moved back to California to be closer to our families, so they’re currently around much more Spanish. We also plan to enroll my daughter in a dual language program in the fall when she’s ready to start kinder. We’re so excited! Thank you again for your note! xox, Vanessa
Maly
May 24, 2016 at 2:47 pmHi Vanessa! I love your blog and appreciate how thoughtful and well-written your posts are. I enjoyed reading this post and just wanted to add my two cents. I’m originally from Venezuela, and both my parents are Chinese. I’m a new mom of two and I’m embarking in this journey of multiracial, multicultural parenthood and loving every minute of it. My parents speak to my sons in Chinese, and my husband and I speak to them in Spanish. Speaking to my sons in Spanish didn’t feel natural at first, but now I love that my 28month old is fluent in all three languages! Plus he talks non-stop! One thing I will suggest to parents trying to raise bilingual children is to not underestimate the power of music! It’s a fun way to learn a language and immerse in the culture! Look for nursery rhymes in Spanish and sing them to your child, or make them up if you will. My son couldn’t keep his attention on more than two pages of a book whenever i tried reading, so I sung to him instead.